FILMS… He Ran All the Way (1951)



A date with a gun…


A heist goes wrong, and one of the robbers meets a young lady. He walks her home and after meeting her family confesses to the crime.


He Ran All the Way (1951) – John Garfield Shelley Winters film noir trailer, Chloroform and Silver Nitrate and photos by United Artists.


With a film ending that will shock you to your very core, He Ran All the Way (1951) has an opening soundtrack that leads you into the movie with a very dramatic title score. The music sets the scene for this compelling film noir movie. It stars as leads John Garfield, in his last movie and Shelley Winters.

This was long before she joined Gene Hackman and Ernest Borgnine in a favourite Christmas themed disaster movie, The Poseidon Adventure (1972). I later saw her in Stanley Kubrick’s Lolita (1962) opposite James Mason. However, this film review belongs to her co-star and leading man, John Garfield who almost steals the show with the complex lead character, Nick Robey.

The opening of the film introduces us to the unemployed Nick Robey (John Garfield), in the opening scene he’s in bed shouting in his sleep whilst having a nightmare. His mother (Gladys George) enters unconcerned and after the pair cross words and it appears there is no love between them. After he dresses – moving his clothes to reveal a gun – and leaves, he meets a friend Al (Norman Lloyd).

Al suggests they carry out their plan to steal 10 thousand dollars in a holdup job for a company’s payroll money, however, Nick is nervous. The pair then head to carry this heist out.  Nick knocks out the security guard and the pair steal the briefcase with the money.

The plan goes awry as a policeman enters the scene, so the pair make a run for it. Al is shot and wounded. Nick on his departure with the money is shot at by this policeman, but the bullets miss him. Nick turns and shoots the policeman wounding him badly. And he runs. And runs. And runs.

Nick then tries to blend in with a crowd. He hides out in a swimming pool – as you do – where he literally bumps into a young lady, Peggy Dobbs (Winters). The pair flirt and he asks to walk her home, but after gripping her arm Peggy becomes fearful of him. But Nick wins her over with an apology. After taking her home, Nick finds she lives with her parents and young brother Tommy. He’s introduced to her family before the family leave for a cinema trip.

After they leave, Peggy and Nick continue to flirt with a few moments where they almost kiss. However, after her family return, he becomes fearful, unintentionally confessing his part in the crime to the stunned Dobbs family. Turning a gun on the family, he decides to stay there to lie low and avoid the police. He stipulates he will hold one of the family hostage as the others carry on their daily life, but if they report the situation to the police that family member will be killed.

In addition to the concern of her parents, there appears to be a growing attraction between Peggy for Nick, However, it is unclear up to and including the final scenes if she loves him or is scared and trying to protect her family. Her parents however are concerned about her feelings, and this multiplies as Nick appears to become more and more unpredictable which is increasingly evident after he learns the policeman he shot has died.

His anxiety and paranoia grow believing every police siren, knock on the door and silence is a bad sign. He loses his temper more easily, but yet at times he can be caring and rational. This erratic behaviour appears to confuse Peggy now almost appearing like she has been betrayed by this nice man she met at the swimming. Later in the film, Nick falls for her and hopes to leave with her for a new life, with her apparently arranging a car so the pair can leave together…

This film as an introduction to the work of John Garfield was a wonderful introduction to this captivating and gifted actor,  He portrayed Nick’s unpredictable behaviour to frightening effect. He conveyed many, many contrasting emotions throughout the movie and scene by scene in this complex character.

Garfield’s performance drew you in from the start, as at first, you felt sorry for this character, then grew to almost like him a little after the initial lovely scenes with Peggy on their meeting to his becoming a quite horrifying man especially when his temper came to the fore.

As the film continued his mood often changed rapidly even within scenes as he became more and more erratic, more frantic to paranoia.  His facial expressions, stance and voice tone changing as often as the weather he became more and more unstable, not trusting anyone and misinterpreting Peggy’s motives for helping him.

After his feelings change for Peggy after the pair shared some passionate kisses, there is desire and passion in his voice. This was in contrast to his later, decreasing trust issues with Peggy which made him a fearful and chilling character, with an excellent nail-biting final scene as the full extent of his distrust materialised.

With the plot, you almost felt that you are hostage with the family as you experience Nick’s stay with them in such detail. Winters particularly showed attraction to love, betrayal to confusion to fear, however, Garfield’s Ropey was oblivious to this caught up in his own plight. Peggy’s parents – wonderfully played by Wallace Ford and Selena Royle – were full of concern for their daughter and her feelings for Nick, and hatred then later ambivalence for Nick.

It was in contrast to her child’s point of view with Tommy (Robert Hyatt) thinking Nick’s crime exciting at first, to later fear and mistrust of his captor. As the film is in black and white, this unintentionally made this film more thrilling and almost hypnotic.

With the tense atmosphere, the use of thunder and lightning also heightened your sense of danger for Peggy and her family. I won’t spoil the final scenes for you but urge you to watch this movie. And that as the film draws to a close that you will be almost spellbound and then the final scene will come and it is dramatic.


Weeper Rating:  😦 /10

Handsqueeze Rating:  🙂 🙂  🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂/10

Hulk Rating: ‎  0‎/10


The John Garfield : The Original Rebel Blogathon 2017, No 6 and Always The Bridesmaid Blogathon 2019 No 69

This was entered for the blogathon run by Phyllis Loves Classic Movies. It was also added to Hollywood Genes’ Always A Bridesmaid Film Blogathon. Other films with this cast include Shelley Winters in Buona Sera Mrs Campbell, The Devils Daughter, The Poseidon Adventure and The Shelley Winters Blogathon Posts.


17 thoughts on “FILMS… He Ran All the Way (1951)

  1. You described this film perfectly!!! I was blown away by Garfield and Winters performances. My other favorite Garfield movies (which are really nearly all the ones I’ve seen) are Four Daughters, The Postman Always Rings Twice, Nobody Lives Forever, and Gentleman’s Agreement.

    Thanks so much for participating in this Blogathon!! I’m glad it introduced you to Garfield 😊

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Hi Gill
    This is my favorite review to date. You captured the whole sense of this movie and Garfield’s performance. This was his last film, for him and his studio. He admits that he did make love to all his leading ladies but 3. Shelley Winters (she probably turning in her grave) is one of them. He said, she cost him (his studio) too much money LOL

    Liked by 1 person

Love your thoughts... but only if they are spoiler free!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.