TV… Fantasy Island (1981) S5 Ep2, Devil and Mr. Roarke / Ziegfeld Girls / Kid Corey Rides Again


The Ziegfeld Girls Visit the Island of Make Believe…


Mr Roarke, Tattoo and Julie meet the plane with a wannabe cowboy, the devil and some one time Ziegfeld girls take a holiday.



Mr. Roarke vs Satan, deeesher


Regular readers will know that I do like a tribute to a movie within a movie or a movie within a TV Show.  I’ve to my delight found more than an a couple of recent homages that way. I reviewed the Fame (1982-87) take on The Wizard of Oz (1939) with Doris taking on the Judy Garland role and the Moonlighting (1985-89) private eyes Maddie and David taking on those film noirs. There’s also more than the one homage to cop films in Hot Fuzz (2007).

Anyway this TV tribute is to Ziegfeld Girls and bizarrely not by some undercover Charlie’s Angels (1976-81) in a flashback and dream episode for Charlie. Which tbh it so should have been. But it’s off to Fantasy Island (1977-84) we go and not I hasten to add with those regular island hosts, Mr Roarke (Ricardo Montalban) and Tattoo (Herve Villechaize) dressed accordingly. This episode also features Julie (Wendy Schaal), Mr Roarke’s god daughter who joined for a season and then left.

Fantasy Island was an 1980s TV series proved that anything and everything can be tributed. This show set on a Pacific Ocean island – with it’s own dancers –  owned by the enigmatic Mr Roarke and his sidekick Tattoo, in their natty matching white suits. There after the guests arrival by plane, the pair let their wildest (for the most part pre watershed) fantasies come true. Although, admittedly those story lines with Jack the Ripper and sex slaves must have gone over my head back then. And during the trip you’d learn something about yourself for the bargain price of $50,000 (worth over 200,000 dollars now).

This Season 5, episode 2 episode of the show has three separate stories named Devil and Mr. Roarke, Ziegfeld Girls  and Kid Corey Rides Again. With a bonus for me that the Ziegfeld Girls segment has (to my joy) two Dallas (1978-91) stars with Dack Rambo (again.. this the second time he’s appeared as a guest star in an 80s show review, after appearing in The Love Boat review, this was also filmed in 1981) and Audrey Landers. This storyline also features Mary Kennedy and Barbi Benton. I’ll briefly look at those other stories within the episode, however the lion’s share of gittering will be about the Ziegfeld Girls story line.


Devil and Mr. Roarke

This was one of a couple of episodes featuring Roddy McDowall as the Devil. His introductory mansplanation by Roarke to Tattoo and Julie implies the trio are more than sceptical about this guest (for all the right reasons). He is introduced as Mr Nick then Mephistopheles. This true identity mansplained by Tattoo. All rightly believing that the Devil has ulterior motives for spending his holiday with them. But Roarke stressing the Devil has every right to holiday there.

However the dastardly one hopes to take Mr Roarke’s immortal soul with him when he goes and bring evil to the island. Mwahahahaha! Needless to say the devil first hopes to capture Julie’s soul first, this easily done by a little bribery and corruption. But then she’s new to her job so she’s a pretty naive.

After a freak accident she asks the Devil for help and he makes a deal with her, he will help in return for her soul. TBH, Julie seems a wee bit too annoyingly bland and she would be more fun as a bad guy anyway but we never find out properly. Shame really as this would have been a fun two parter especially after the Devil possesses Julie at one point to try and fool Roarke.

Mr Roarke, being the gallant one is willing to sacrifice his soul to help his goddaughter out. Then its a verbal battle between the Devil and Roarke which would put Hobbs and Shaw to shame. This particular part of the story is the most fun bit. I really loved watching McDowall and Montalban at loggerheads, both camping and hamming it up and both trying to outwit each other. I could have quite easily watched an episode of just these two characters with Tattoo providing commentary and refreshments. This part of the episode also boasting some cool early 1980s special effects which added to the absurdity of the plot and conclusion of the story.


Kid Corey Rides Again

This episode features Ned Plummer (Arte Johnson), a cowboy fanatic who wants to visit the Wild West and meet his hero Kid Corey (Jack Elam), a legendary outlaw. Corey was a famed legend who disappeared with 1 million dollars worth of bank loot after a robbery and was never heard of again. With Julie and Tattoo believing he’s only after the money. This part of the episode reminded me a bit of the Westworld (1973) film but with a darker twist. Roarke mansplains when this particular guest returns to the past, he’s dodging real bullets from real guns adding to the “drama” (read comedy).

It throws Plummer – his costume possibly inspiring the man in black from the Westworld (2016-) TV Series – straight into the action with him arriving and involved in a gun fight. Plummer meets and tries to bond with his hero. After Corey nicks his horse, Plummer’s disillusioned with Corey. He’s quite sad as finds out he’s not the nice guy and Robin Hood character that he’s read about. But its Red Letter Media heaven with the plot eventually leading to us meeting Cameron Mitchell as a Sheriff. This after the pair are imprisoned and Plummer is “mistaken” for Corey.

TBH part of me secretly hoped he’d get shot pretty early on to concentrate on the other stories.  But then I’m not a Western fan, so this might be more your thing if it is. Tattoo joins him sporadically for this storyline and “helps” out with the plot line. Tattoo sadly didn’t have much to do here in the Wild West and in the whole episode. But I did enjoy his rapport with Montalban. This pair had more chemistry and rapport, than with Schaal, but this I’m sure improved as the series progressed so I can’t really judge as this her second episode in this character.


and now that storyline presenting those…

Ziegfeld Girls

With impeccable timing the elderly Joan Michaels (Barbi Benton) and Rubi Rogers (Audrey Landers)  – aka Landers and Benton heavily made up in unconvincing “old” make up and wearing “elderly wardrobe” – visit the island escaping from their retirement home. Poor Tattoo (and probably your grandad) had hoped the visiting showgirls would be a couple of pretty young things.

In their intro to the others, the cunning Mr Roarke confides with Tattoo and Julie that this pair of Missouri ladies will learn about their friendship. Saying this friendship will be tested it to the limits. This pair were both Ziegfeld Girls in Broadway in 1926, and now they are arriving just in time to appear the island’s revival show on the Ziegfeld Girls. With both wishing to be young again.

Roarke and Julie take the women to see the dance rehearsal. Both are mightily impressed by the natty cardboard cutout of Ziegfeld. It turns out Michaels’s granddaughter, Billie (Betty Kennedy) is in the show and she’s hoping to follow in her grandmother’s footsteps. She’s dating and madly in love with the show’s director,  Carl Wagner (Dack Rambo). He’s keen to get some tips for the show, but Joan is not keen to be the show’s consultant but to be young again. She tells Roarke just that.

Roarke meets with Joan and Rubi and produces two life size cardboard cut outs of them as they were in their youth in their Ziegfeld costumes. Roarke stresses their rules within their fantasy are that they can’t say who they are or they will be old again, they can’t tell they are there as part of a “fantasy” and it’s time limited for one weekend only. After Roarke takes them back to then with some natty positive visualisation with his dulcet Mexican accent, reminding them of their Ziegfeld Days. Suddenly the old women are then rejuvenated looking like they did then. Cue girly squeals of delight.

The pair – now in modern day wear – goes to watch dance rehearsals with them criticising the show in a stage whisper. Then after Carl overhears them, he asks them to show what they can do. Joan gives an inspirational speech to the dancers. Rubi shows him exactly what the “Flo would have done” and her best dance moves..

He asks the pair to become dancers in his show. Carl takes a bit of a fancy to Rubi, which Joan begs her friend not to act on as Rubi has always had a thing about directors. But Rubi does end up snogging Carl as she’s quite enjoying being young again especially with this young man falling for her.. much to her friend’s annoyance. The story line also concentrating on the women’s friendship, where a few comments tells us more of their life stories and personalities, and revelations and confessions are made.

For the Ziegfeld Follies theme itself, this was recreated throughout storyline. Montalban’s positive visualisation taking the elderly characters back to their youth was a lovely touch. It comprised of a black and white slideshow with of many of those key players  – including Gerswin and Al Johnson – in the Ziegfeld Follies story. This was a much more memorable tribute to this topic than an explanation, and beautifully put together piece. These slides were superimposed over then what looked like a colour blurry clip from the dance scene later in the show.

Barbi Benton and Audrey Landers wore Ziegfeld Girls costumes (complete with plumes) at least twice. These glamorous costumes were beautifully made and easily recreating this time and place. Other Ziegfeld touches included the later dance (not blurry this time) and some apt musical numbers which reminded the women of their past experiences and in the later dance scene. Sadly there are few pictures of this particular part of the episode.

Interestingly, all these actors and actresses had made many journeys to the island. Audrey Landers appeared five times in the show and Barbi Benton eight times and Dack Rambo six times. The Devil himself having the last laugh. McDowall’s plans as the devil to create an evil island came true, after this particular TV series ended. In this series, where Montalban believed his character Roarke is believed to be a fallen but immortal angel. This series returned for a one off reboot of the show in 1998. Mr Roarke was played by another part of the McDowall clan, the McDowells.  This as Malcolm McDowell played Mr Roarke in a more devilish take on things…

Weeper Rating: 😦  😦 😦 /10

Handsqueeze Rating:   🙂 🙂  🙂  /10

Hulk Rating: ‎   mrgreenmrgreenmrgreen‎/10


The Great Ziegfeld Blogathon 2020 No 11

This review was added to Hollywood Genes’ The Great Ziegfeld Blogathon 2020 . Other reviews with this cast include a wee review of Fantasy Island HERE. Others include Landers, Montalban, Rambo and Benton in The Love Boat and Murder She Wrote. Landers also starred inHoteland with Rambo in Dallas. Montalban in The Colbys and Dynasty. Villechaize appeared in The Fall Guy.  Wendy Schaal also starred in Happy Days and Innerspace.


15 thoughts on “TV… Fantasy Island (1981) S5 Ep2, Devil and Mr. Roarke / Ziegfeld Girls / Kid Corey Rides Again

    1. I understand how you feel actually, hated that too and also in other shows like Family Ties. But at least there was no canned laughter, my major peeve abut some shows from back then. Just as well they have the moral trope in Dallas, JR wouldn’t have been the same if he’d kept seeing the error of his ways.


Love your (spoiler -free) thoughts...

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.